From Hedge Funds to Olipop: Lessons in Early-Stage Investing with Alex Malamatinas

In this week’s episode of Turning Pro, we sat down with Alex Malamatinas, founder of Melitas Ventures. Alex’s journey from finance to venture capital is packed with valuable lessons for anyone in the startup world. Raised in a household where consumer brands were the norm, his father led companies like Burger King and Smirnoff, Alex’s passion for consumer packaged goods (CPG) was ignited early on.

Today, Alex is known for his ability to combine sharp financial analysis with a hands-on approach to working with founders. In this episode, he dives into the traits he looks for in early-stage entrepreneurs, how he assesses brands with potential, and the tough lessons he’s learned - like passing on Liquid Death at a $20M valuation.

Find Season 2, Episode 13 of the Turning Pro podcast on Apple, Spotify, or YouTube.

Here Are the Top 10 Lessons We Learned from Alex Malamatinas:

1. Blend Analytics with Passion: Alex’s transition from hedge funds to venture capital uniquely positions him to blend financial analysis with hands-on support for consumer brands. He emphasizes that while numbers are important, his true passion lies in helping founders. This combination of analytics and human connection has helped Melitas Ventures stand out in a crowded field.

2. Focus on Early Traction: For Alex, early-stage consumer brands need to show signs of market traction before he invests. He focuses on data like sales velocity and margins, as seen in his early investment in Olipop. Traction, rather than just ideas, is key in determining a brand’s future success.

3. Resilience is Non-Negotiable: Resilience is a top quality Alex looks for in founders. He believes founders must possess the ability to push through challenges and stay committed to their vision. Passion is important, but without the grit to endure tough times, success is unlikely.

4. Learn from the Misses: Alex candidly shares a lesson from passing on Liquid Death when it was valued at $20 million. Despite missing this opportunity, he sees it as a reminder that even experienced investors will make mistakes. The key is to continuously learn from them and improve.

5. Bet on Health-Conscious Trends: Alex is focused on brands that align with modern, health-conscious consumer behavior. Trends like multicultural foods, fragrance, and pet care excite him because they reflect evolving consumer demands. He believes these trends will continue to shape the future of CPG innovation.

6. Value Complementary Skills in Teams: In his experience, successful founders understand that building a strong, complementary team is critical. Alex often points to examples like the founders of Olipop and Magic Spoon, who combined different skills early on to drive their brands forward.

7. Understand Your Market: Deep knowledge of the market is crucial for any founder. Alex emphasizes the importance of knowing your product, understanding consumer needs, and keeping up with industry trends. Founders who fail to grasp these essentials are less likely to succeed.

8. Trust the Data, Even When It’s Hard: While passion is essential, Alex underscores the importance of trusting data, especially when it reveals difficult truths. In some cases, ignoring warning signs like poor unit economics or high cash burn can lead to failed investments. He advises that it’s better to face reality and make tough decisions early.

9. Patience Pays Off: Alex’s experience shows that early-stage investing requires patience. He’s not looking for quick wins but instead evaluates potential over the long term. This methodical approach helps Melitas Ventures back brands that may take time to scale but have the potential for significant growth.

10. Adapt with the Market: The consumer landscape is constantly changing, and Alex’s approach reflects this reality. He acknowledges that strategies that worked five years ago might not work today, highlighting the importance of staying flexible and evolving with the market. This adaptability is crucial for long-term success in CPG investing.

Alex Malamatinas’ insights offer invaluable wisdom for anyone in the consumer brand space, whether you’re an entrepreneur, investor, or simply curious about what makes a brand succeed.

This season of Turning Pro is delivered to you by ShipPlug. They use data-driven insights to optimize shipping for companies, saving them time and money.

Subscribe to the podcast here to be notified about future episodes.